A description of the two sources about haig and the battle of somme in some

The French, with slighter opposition and with far more heavy artillery—as well as aided by the fact that they were less expected—made a deeper advance.

Battle of the Somme – a summary

It is most likely reliable and shows how many people died on the first day of the Somme. In return, the Germans suffered casualties that first day.

This image of the Generals was most likely brought about by the consequences of bad tactics at the Battle of the Somme and was the feeling of many British citizens. But the success was short-lived. The Battle of the Somme was designed to relieve the pressure on the French suffering at Verdun.

He advocated a simpler advance. Here are some facts about that battle. The second line was beyond the range of Allied field artillery, so as to force an attacker to stop and move field artillery forward before assaulting the line.

Consequently, though Haig drew attention to the German probing methods at Verdun, when Rawlinson settled for linear attack, Haig did not feel that he could override him. The crater that had once been Hawthorn Redoubt should, in British minds, have been an area of success.

Was the Battle of the Somme a failure Essay

Thousands of British soldiers got out of their trenches and began to advance on the German lines. Bythe British had adopted a French tactic. When a more flexible policy was substituted later, decisions about withdrawal were still reserved to army commanders.

Troops moved forward in waves, each one moving through its predecessors while they consolidated their hold on the ground that had been taken. Battle of Guillemont The Battle of Guillemont was an attack on the village which was captured by the Fourth Army on the first day.

In order to have free passage for the cavalry, Haig ordered the artillery units the task of destroying the German defensive lines. The next day, he declared the Battle over.

13 Facts – The Battle Of The Somme – One Of The Bloodiest Battles In Human History

Only on the south of the British front, near Fricourt and Montauban, did the attack gain a real footing in the German defenses. Soldiers from every part of the Empire were thrown into the melee — Australian, Canadian, New Zealanders, Indian and South African all took their part.

A German spy is giving away every one of our battle plans. They had three layers of trench lines; concrete bunkers dug deep into the ground, and extensive maps of the local terrain.

However the Germans that were killed were different to the British that were killed. From the beginning of the battle, the Allies had dominated the skies.

Who fought at the Battle of the Somme? My instincts lead me to deduce that we are at last about to go over the top.

Battle of the Somme Map. Silence as the Signal On the morning of July 1,the British detonated massive explosions under key German positions.

However, his plans was outlined in the second period of the struggle when three quarters of his troops were concentrated on a continuous front, while in that period, most of the daily battles were small-scaled.

He says that the Battle of the Somme was a failure unlike Haig who says that the British proved they could force Germany out of a strong position. The front trenches were on a forward slope, lined by white chalk from the subsoil and easily seen by ground observers.

After eight days, on July 1,they ordered the attack. That result and its causes cast a strange reflection on the words which Haig had written on the eve of the attack: Having gained air superiority, the Germans launched a massive infantry attack, sending thousands of soldiers over the top.

Or, on the contrary, did it contribute to the defeat of Germany? This description conveys this sense of confidence similar to Source C. However, the Germans were warned of the bombardment.First Battle of the Somme: “Increasing optimism” was shown by Haig as the day of battle drew nearer, though the resources of the French and, “No suggestion was made to utilize the successes gained by some to assist in improving the situation of those who had failed.” The unconcealed preparations and the long bombardment had.

This source was published shortly after the war inbut was a few years after the Battle of the Somme allowing some time for the truth about the events of the battle to emerge. The source has some limitations as it was an extract from Haig’s own writing, who was Commander-in-Chief of the British Forces therefore the source may be bias.

Sections. Primary Sources; Student Activities; References; The Battle of the Somme was planned as a joint French and British operation.

The idea originally came from the French Commander-in-Chief, Joseph Joffre and was accepted by General Douglas Haig, the British Expeditionary Force (BEF) commander, despite his preference for a large.

These sources are not about Haig and the Battle of the Somme Essay

The offensive was planned by the British Commander, Douglas Haig. What was the Plan? On the 1st Julythe battle of the Somme began.

Sources A, D, The Battle had some positive and negative views. The best thing that happened. SOURCE 4 – Sir Douglas Haig explaining the importance of heavy artillery at the Battle of the Somme in his book, dispatches, that was published after the war.

The enemy's position to be attacked was of a very formidable character, situated on a. Source D is useful to us as it is based on true historical events - These sources are not about Haig and the Battle of the Somme introduction. Even though truth is exaggerated people know what events are being talked about.

Source D is a picture form Black adder once popular war comedy. It is.

A description of the two sources about haig and the battle of somme in some
Rated 5/5 based on 46 review